REFEREE REVIEW FORM

Paper Number :
Title of the manuscript :
Referee Number : 1 2 3

Instructions for Referees

Please evaluate for each category and check an overall assessment of the paper and provide comments and recommendations if necessary. Detailed comments and recommendations should not be written in the text, but should be numerically listed on separate sheets of paper that do not reveal your identify or affiliation. Minor wording or grammatical changes can be indicated in red pen or pencil in the text. Please return this review form and the paper to the KIDS Office.

EVALUATION :

1.	Is this a new and original contribution? :Yes ( ) : No ( )
2.	Is it clearly presented and well organized, and is the English usage satisfactory? Grammatical correction of English usage will be proof-read by the KIDS if accepted for publication : Yes ( ) : No ( )
3.	Does it give adequate references to related work? :Yes ( ) : No ( )
4.	Does the abstract at the beginning provide an adequate summary of the work performed, the results and conclusions? :Yes ( ) : No ( )
5.	Are the figures satisfactory, with no extraneous information and with symbols and exponents written correctly? :Yes ( ) : No ( )
6.	Are the conclusions sound and justified by the results presented? :Yes ( ) : No ( )

OVERALL ASSESSMENT AND RECOMMENDATION (Check one)

______ (A)	: PUBLISH AS IS (exclusive of minor typographic or grammatical corrections)
______ (B)	: PUBLISH, subject to minor technical changes
______ (C)	: PROVISIONALLY ACCEPTABLE FOR PUBLICATION (subject to major technical revision)
______ (D)	:REJECT (serious technical deficiencies or English usage exceptionally poor)
______ (E)	:RECOMMEND TO OTHER JOURNALS

Please elaborate more on any “no” answer to the above on a separate sheet. If you cannot evaluate this paper and want to recommend someone else, please inform KIDS office with his/her name, title and full address including e-mail as soon as possible.